Oak hardwood floor running from the foyer into the kitchen and living area
Hardwood Floor Guide

Hardwood vs Luxury Vinyl Plank: Which Floor Makes Sense for Your Kansas City Home?

By Good Ol' Boy Hardwood Floors • • 7 min read

We get asked this a lot, usually by someone standing in a room with worn carpet or tired floors and a stack of samples from a big box store. Luxury vinyl plank, or LVP, has come a long way. From across the room, a good one can pass for wood. So the question of hardwood vs luxury vinyl plank is a fair one, and the honest answer depends on the room and how long you plan to live with the floor.

We are a hardwood company, so you know where our bias sits. We will still tell you plainly where vinyl makes more sense.

What Each Floor Actually Is

  • Solid hardwood is one piece of wood, usually three-quarters of an inch thick, nailed to a wood subfloor. It can be sanded and refinished many times over its life.
  • Engineered hardwood is a real wood layer on a plywood or composite core. It looks and feels like solid, and depending on how thick the top layer is, it may be refinishable.
  • Luxury vinyl plank is a plastic plank with a printed wood image under a clear wear layer. Most of what is sold for homes today has a rigid core and clicks together as a floating floor.

How to tell what floor you have covers the differences in more detail if you are not sure what is in your house now.

Water: Where Vinyl Wins

Most rigid core vinyl is sold as waterproof, and the planks themselves do shrug off spills, pet accidents and wet boots. Hardwood does not like standing water. A slow dishwasher leak or a pet that keeps using the same corner can cup and stain boards.

Two things are worth knowing. First, waterproof planks do not make a waterproof floor. Water that gets through the seams or around the edges can sit on the subfloor underneath, where it can cause mold and subfloor damage that nobody sees. Second, hardwood handles ordinary kitchen life better than its reputation suggests, as long as spills get wiped up. Hardwood floors in kitchens goes into that.

For basements, full bathrooms and laundry rooms, vinyl is usually the more practical choice. Solid hardwood does not belong below grade or in a room that gets wet every day.

Wear and Scratches

A vinyl plank is only as durable as its wear layer, the clear top coat over the printed image. Thicker wear layers resist scratches well. But once a gouge or a worn traffic lane cuts through to the print, there is nothing to sand and nothing to refinish. The plank has to be replaced.

Hardwood scratches and dents more easily, especially softer species and higher-gloss finishes. The difference is what happens next. Light wear in the finish can be fixed with a screen and recoat, and deeper scratches come out with a full sand and refinish. Pet scratches on hardwood explains how much of that damage is only in the finish.

Repairs

Damaged hardwood boards can be cut out and new boards woven in, then sanded and finished so the repair blends into the floor. Matching new hardwood to an existing floor shows how that works.

Vinyl planks can be replaced too, but in a floating click floor that often means taking up every plank between the wall and the damaged one. And if the product line has been discontinued, finding a match a few years later can be hard. It is worth keeping a spare box in the garage.

Lifespan

This is the biggest difference. A vinyl floor lasts as long as its wear layer, then it gets replaced. A solid hardwood floor gets refinished instead. Plenty of the oak floors we sand in older Kansas City homes are the original floors in the house, and with care they will go on for decades more. Refinish or replace covers what makes a floor worth saving.

Feel, Sound and Look

  • Underfoot. Nailed hardwood feels solid. Floating vinyl can feel softer and sound hollow or clicky, though a good underlayment helps.
  • Up close. Real wood never repeats. Vinyl uses a set number of printed images, and in a large room you can often spot the same plank twice.
  • Over time. Wood changes color with light and age. Oak ambers and cherry darkens. Vinyl stays the color it was printed. Whether that is good or bad depends on what you like. Why hardwood changes color in sunlight explains what to expect.
  • Changing the look. Hardwood can be sanded and stained a new color when your taste changes. Vinyl cannot.

Kansas City Humidity

Our hot, humid summers and dry winters make wood move. Hardwood floors open small gaps in winter and close them in summer, and a floor installed without proper acclimation can cup. Keeping the house roughly in the 30 to 50 percent humidity range most wood flooring manufacturers ask for prevents most of that. Why gaps open in winter covers the cycle. Vinyl is less affected by humidity, though rigid core planks do expand with heat, which matters in rooms with a lot of sun.

Room by Room

  • Living rooms, dining rooms, bedrooms and halls: hardwood. These rooms are where it looks and lasts best.
  • Kitchens: either works. Hardwood ties the kitchen into the rest of the main floor. Vinyl is the lower-worry option for a busy household.
  • Stairs: hardwood treads, which hold up far better than vinyl wrapped over a stair nose. Hardwood stairs and treads has more.
  • Basements, full baths and laundry rooms: vinyl, or engineered hardwood rated for the space where wood is a must.

If You Already Have Hardwood

We often meet homeowners about to cover a worn oak floor with vinyl because they assume it is beyond saving. Most of the time it is not. A refinish costs less than many people expect and keeps a floor that can be renewed again later. Before you buy vinyl for a room that has wood under the carpet or under the scratches, have someone look at it. Hardwood under carpet explains what we usually find.

Get an Honest Opinion

We install and refinish hardwood across the metro, from Kansas City to Overland Park, Lee's Summit and Liberty. Whether you need new hardwood, refinishing or removal of an old floor first, get a free estimate and we will tell you which floor makes sense for each room.

Get a Free Estimate

Have a floor you want looked at? We give honest, no-pressure estimates across the Kansas City metro.

Good to Know

Hardwood vs Luxury Vinyl Plank: Which Floor Makes Sense for Your Kansas City Home?: Common Questions

It depends on the room. Hardwood lasts longer because it can be sanded and refinished many times, and it suits living areas, bedrooms and stairs. Vinyl handles water better and makes more sense in basements, full bathrooms and laundry rooms.

Most rigid core planks are waterproof, but the floor as a whole is not. Water can get through seams and around edges and sit on the subfloor underneath, where it can cause damage nobody sees.

Usually, yes. But hardwood scratches can be fixed with a recoat or a refinish. Once vinyl is scratched or worn through its wear layer, the plank has to be replaced.

No. There is no wood on the surface to sand. A worn or damaged vinyl floor gets individual planks replaced or the whole floor replaced.

Have the hardwood looked at first. Many worn oak floors can be refinished for less than people expect, and a refinished floor can be renewed again later. Vinyl over good hardwood hides a floor that could have been saved.

Solid hardwood should not go below grade. Engineered hardwood can in some basements if the slab is tested for moisture and the product is rated for it. For many basements, vinyl is the more practical choice.

Ready for floors you'll be proud of?

Get a free, no-pressure estimate from Kansas City’s trusted hardwood team.